Judge orders Microsoft to stop selling Word

DALLAS, Aug. 11 /PRNewswire/ – The national law firm of McKool Smith is announcing a permanent injunction and total damages and interest of more than $290 million against software giant Microsoft Corp. (NASDAQ: MSFT) in a Texas patent infringement lawsuit won by Toronto-based technology provider i4i Inc.

The Order and Permanent Injunction were signed today by Judge Leonard Davis of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, Tyler Division. Today’s ruling follows a May 20, 2009, verdict of $200 million after jurors found that Redmond, Wash.-based Microsoft willfully infringed an i4i patent covering a document system that relies on the XML custom formatting function.

During the trial, attorneys from McKool Smith and Tyler, Texas-based Parker, Bunt & Ainsworth successfully argued that Microsoft infringed the i4i patent issued in 1998, U.S. Patent No. 5,787,499, which covers software designed to manipulate “document architecture and content.” The software covered by the patent removed the need for individual, manually embedded command codes to control text formatting in electronic documents.
Continues at;

McKool Smith :: McKool Smith: Judge Upholds Verdict, Enhances Damages, Issues Permanent Injunction Against Microsoft in Patent Infringement Lawsuit


On Tuesday, a judge ordered Microsoft to stop selling Word, its flagship word processing software and one of the main components of the Microsoft Office System - namely part of Word 2003 and Word 2007. This also now extends to Word 2010 which contains the same feature set.

Judge Leonard Davis of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas issued a permanent injunction that “prohibits Microsoft from selling or importing to the United States any Microsoft Word products that have the capability of opening .XML, .DOCX or DOCM files (XML files) containing custom XML,” according to a statement released by attorneys for the plantiff, i4i, CNET reports. Microsoft stated that it planned to appeal the verdict. i4i sued Microsoft in March 2007 that Microsoft violated its 1998 patent (No. 5,787,449) for a document system that "eliminated the need for manually embedded formatting codes. "

XML (Extensible Markup Language) is considered a “page description language,” with one of its key features being that humans are able to read it legibly, not just PC’s and other devices. XML allows developers to create their own tags for data.

In May 2009, a jury in Tyler, Texas, ruled in favor of i4i that the custom XML tagging of Word 2003 and Word 2007 infringed on the patent owned by i4i and ordered Microsoft to pay $200 million in compensation.

In Tuesday’s ruling, Microsoft was also ordered to pay an additional $40 million for willful infringement, as well as $37 million in prejudgment interest. Microsoft must comply with the injunction within 60 days and the injunction specifically states that Microsoft way not test, demonstrate or market Word products that contain the XML feature in question.

The Microsoft Office system overall generated a 9.3 billion dollar profit in 2008 alone, and this move would hurt that business immensely.
Source: Judge orders Microsoft to stop selling Word


Eastern District of Texas huh? Ah yes, one of those patent trolls. Software patents bad!

In this case the enemy of your enemy is not necessarily your friend.

Pfft! Like it will make any difference at all. They will merely use their financial might and/or political connections to silence/rub out the opposition.

Or just stick to the “same procedure as every year” and ignore it, that approach hasn’t failed them yet ;).

I wonder if this effects .odt too, isnt that based on the .xml too?

Next round. Judge orders Microsoft to stop selling Windows as it founds it guilty on infringing a gazillion of patents.

/me does a little dance :stuck_out_tongue:

I agree with you.

I have been against software patents for a long time, if M$ cant get this appealed Open Office could be the next to take a hit as well.


as of today all of the ms office suites are no longer available on technet

I take that back it’s working again

Here’s a video with a radio interview of the CEO of i4i the company that started this suit.
Judge orders Microsoft to stop selling Word | Microsoft - CNET News