Not sure if anyone else has had this problem before, so here goes.
I recently installed openSUSE 11.2 64-bit with KDE and after running through the necessary installations for the sound/graphics card drivers and then running the YaST update I found that Flash player has no sound whatsoever, regardless of the browser used. Long story short, after a bit of searching and probing around the net and this forum, I managed to pin it down to something Chrysantine said not that long ago in this thread:
I had a person today in IRC who said they had complete sound in the system otherwise but none in Flash. It turned out to be because Flash was using the first detected soundcard in the system, listed in /proc/asound/cards rather than the real card they wanted.
So when I went to look inside said file, sure enough the wrong sound card was set as number 1, and the card I wanted to use as number 2 as shown below:
1 [Intel ]: HDA-Intel - HDA Intel
HDA Intel at 0xf9ff8000 irq 22
2 [DX ]: AV200 - Xonar DX
Asus Virtuoso 100 (rev 2) at 0xd800, irq 18
So I went to open it in KWrite and then saved the changes under the same name, except under the Documents folder since the original was read-only under normal circumstances and KWrite wouldn’t let me write over it due to not having the permissions for it. Then I opened ‘Applications’ > ‘System’ > ‘File Manager’ > ‘File Manager - Super User Mode’, hoping that this would enable me to simply copy and paste the file in question without being prompted about permissions. However this won’t let me copy and paste into the folder mentioned by Chrysantine. I right-click the file and choose copy, but when I go to right click into the other folder the paste option is greyed out. I can paste it pretty much anywhere else but not this folder for whatever reason.
Any ideas why? Is there something I’ve missed here? Is there perhaps a way to open KWrite in super user mode? Any help would be appreciated.
Under YaST they are in the correct order I want them in. The Xonar DX is card 0, the HDA Intel (on-board) is card 1. Also if it helps I can get sound everywhere else.
The problem is /proc/asound/cards isn’t a real file. Files under /proc are not real files. It is a pseudo-file that when read, displays some internal kernel state. This particular pseudo-file is always read-only. Chrysantine was reading it for problem solving. To actually modify the order of the sound cards the file to edit is /etc/modprobe.d/50-sound.conf, in particular the “alias” lines. It should be self-explanatory.
So today you have learnt another fact about Linux.
Going to bed now, it’s around 02:40 here in the UK as I write this. Will pick this up in the morning (or afternoon, whichever is more convenient for me ;)). Thanks for the input…
The strange thing from the output of your /proc/asound/cards is that your numbering starts from 1. Mine starts at 0, and is in the order specified by the aliases in /etc/modprobe.d/50-sound.conf. Perhaps somewhere in the bootup sequence you deactivated card 0 and reactivated it? I don’t have any better ideas, this is the first time I’m seeing this kind of sequence.
I assume you have done a reboot?
If it doesn’t work I would simply delete all entries in YaST and redetect them in the right order.
Yes I did do a reboot afterward. When that seemed to make no difference I tried the latter method in YaST and unfortunately this resulted in catastrophe: the card I wanted to redetect wouldn’t let me do it, it kept giving me some error in loading the kernel module snd-oxygen. I did a bit of searching and the only relevent info I could find linked to this thread which then led to this article toward the end of the thread. However I’ve ruled out the possibility of the latter after the required probing was done. So I did a full re-install of openSUSE to get the sound back, not ideal really but since there wasn’t much I’d saved on there no big loss really.
Since then I’ve looked at the /proc/asound/cards file again and it’s the same story with regard to starting from 1 rather than 0. If it helps, during the boot sequence, I do hear a loud clicking sound coming from my sound card to tell me it’s being activated. This loud click can be heard once each time I boot into Windows, and is also heard (sometimes twice) when I boot into openSUSE. Perhaps this is what’s causing /proc/asound/cards to start from 1 rather than 0? I’m not sure if any other Asus Xonar DX owners can vouch for this same sound, but at least the card itself seems to be fine.
Perhaps it would be wise to log this with the ALSA team, as suggested at the end of the above linked thread. Also this thread seems to be tailing off from its original title so I’ll probably start a new thread if I get any more problems later down the line.
I just installed Opensuse and i didn’t have sound for flash, but i had it for Amarok. I checked and I had the PCM volume to 0. I dont think it is going to be something so simple as that, but check anyway.
jonitfcfan wrote:
> I don’t actually have a PCM slider in the KMix dialogue, I even tried
> ‘Settings’ > ‘Configure Channels’, it’s not there . Not to
> worry for now.
no, i’d worry a LOT, if you are missing a slider that everyother KMix
has it points to a problem much bigger than just no sound!
to me it sounds like a damaged or incomplete install…
did you install from DVD? put it back in, boot from it and run the
media check, and if it passes then run “Repair Installed System” while
connected to the net…if you still don’t have a slider when that is
done, open YaST and remove KMix and immediately install KMix…
if you still have no slider do this at a command line and copy paste
it back to this thread:
Just finished both the md5sum check and the Media Check feature in YaST, both of which come out unscathed. If I run the ‘Repair Installed System’ option when booting from the DVD again, will this wipe out any software that was installed after the openSUSE installation (e.g. VLC Media Player, HandBrake etc)?
I’ve done the repair installation, that didn’t make a difference. I then tried to uninstall and reinstall KMix as suggested (I even tried doing a reboot after the uninstallation at one point), that didn’t give me the PCM slider either. I guess now there’s only one thing left to do on the list:
If it also helps please find below two screenshots: first with the sliders I currently have shown, second with all the sliders currently available under the ‘Configure Channels’ option in KMix:
ok i see i should have looked at your repos sooner…
set these to disabled and no automatic refresh: 1,2, 5, 6 & 9
leaving these enabled and refreshing: 3, 4, 7, 8
I’ve just finished completing all the steps asked of me, thank you very much for your input. Now I guess there’s one more thing for you to do, to quote you from earlier:
In YaST I get no sliders at all when I go to change the volume under the Sound control panel, and the sound test doesn’t yield anything. This bit doesn’t concern me as I can indeed get sound from anything except Flash Player as mentioned in previous posts.
Tried it, didn’t make any difference (I even restarted for good measure).
. Not to worry for now.