Licensing question - ISV

Hi there,

We’re a ISV and we distribute a product which requires Mono for Linux (all flavors).

My question is:

  • Our product is proprietary
  • Are we allowed to build packages using OBS?
  • Can we add dependencies so that people can easily install our package + the latest mono build (we can build it in OBS too)?
  • Should we pay a fee? If so: who should we contact?
  • Is there any professional service we can hire to help us setting up the whole thing?

Thanks,

pablo

On Thu, 17 Jan 2013 22:36:01 +0000, codice wrote:

Don’t know definitively on the other questions you asked, but for:

> * Is there any professional service we can hire to help us setting up
> the whole thing?

http://openbuildservice.org/support/

It sounds like a private instance may be beneficial for you, given that
your product is proprietary.

Jim

Jim Henderson
openSUSE Forums Administrator
Forum Use Terms & Conditions at http://tinyurl.com/openSUSE-T-C

Hi Jim,

Thanks for the answer.

We’ll need to build our own machine then.

Question: do you know anyone who would be interested on a contract work to create the service and configure it to build Mono and Package our Plastic SCM (Plastic SCM - distributed version control system (DVCS)) software? We’d love to do that ASAP so if anyone is interested we’d be happy to talk.

Thanks,

pablo

On Wed, 06 Feb 2013 13:06:01 +0000, psantosl wrote:

> Hi Jim,
>
> Thanks for the answer.

No problem. :slight_smile:

> Question: do you know anyone who would be interested on a contract work
> to create the service and configure it to build Mono and Package our
> Plastic SCM (‘Plastic SCM - distributed version control system (DVCS)’
> (http://www.plasticscm.com)) software? We’d love to do that ASAP so if
> anyone is interested we’d be happy to talk.

I don’t myself, but if I hear of anyone who’s looking, I’ll send them
your way. :slight_smile:

Jim


Jim Henderson
openSUSE Forums Administrator
Forum Use Terms & Conditions at http://tinyurl.com/openSUSE-T-C

As to my little experience:

[1] Do you plan to distribute your proprietary product with openSUSE and let users use it freely in openSUSE? (you can still sell for other cases)

[2] Can you stand that you have to upload your source code to build.opensuse.org then everybody can see it by downloading the tarball? (it’s possible to “strip” source from the end products, but “to build” means b.o.o needs your source code.

If the answer is yes, go contact Adrian/Coolo on openSUSE buildservice list. And you have to prepare a re-distribution license for openSUSE.

If the answer is no, you have to set up your own build service.

  • Our product is proprietary

That’s OK, if you want to and we allow you to distribute it with openSUSE, you can use the NON-OSS repo like Flash.

  • Are we allowed to build packages using OBS?

It depends. OBS can only be used to package LIBRE softwares with source codes and the close-source softwares which are part of openSUSE.

  • Can we add dependencies so that people can easily install our package + the latest mono build (we can build it in OBS too)?

Yes you can. Even in your private build service, you can still link the free packages in OBS to build your proprietary software as dependency (see pmbs.links2linux.org Projects, there’re linked projects) . But you can’t re-use the codes of the free packages.

  • Should we pay a fee? If so: who should we contact?

Someone asked exactly the same questions on buildservice mailing lists some time ago. And Adrian refused him.

No you don’t need to pay a fee for contents on OBS. and we don’t accept fees. But you have to obey our rules( see [1] and [2]).

If you want to setup private OBS, the OBS is still free to you, but you may have to pay for Consulting fees if you need help.

  • Is there any professional service we can hire to help us setting up the whole thing?

Yes

  • Is there anyone available to be hired to build?

It depends on how much you pay and how big your project is…

And here on forums you can’t meet your targets…you need to ask on opensuse-packaging mailing list.

PS: If you can have the private OBS ready, I’m available to be hired to package.

Greetings,

Marguerite