Hi all, (Sorry if the title is a little messy - it sounds like just a bunch of random words when I read it out loud to myself
For a while I have been using a dual monitor setup, which has the adverse effect of permanently keeping the graphics card in 3d high performance mode. This leads to increased power consumption and higher card temperatures (mine (Nvidia) is 70-75*C when idle).
Although I tried to find a solution in the beginning, I found out that there is none and just decided to live with the increased fan noise. Now recently I stumbled upon this software workaround that is supposed to fix this issue, but it appears to be available for Windows only. I was wondering, though, and that’s why searched the forums/internet and decided to post this, whether anyone knows if this (or something similar) is available for OpenSUSE as well?
If you load the proprietary video driver and install nvidia-settings, seems like you can control your power saving settings. What nVIDIA card do you have and are you loading their proprietary video drive?
Thanks James for your fast reply. I have an nVIDIA Quadro FX 700M and nvidia-settings installed, but although I can choose the ‘PowerMizer Settings’ ‘Preferred Mode’ (Adaptive or Prefer Maximum Performance) it doesn’t ever drop below the highest performance level with a second monitor hooked up. Even though I have selected ‘Adaptive’, it says the performance mode is ‘Maximum Performance’. Am I maybe overlooking something?
So, looking through the many posts on this subject I did find this:
I have a multimonitor setup and the video card is always at max speed even with PowerMizer disabled.
When the graphic card detects two or more monitors, it will clock itself to Max. performance profile no matter what the PowerMizer parameters are. This is in the NVIDIA specs.
Their reasoning is said to be because driving dual monitors and power saving at the same time will produce bad results and I guess they think cooling will take care of its self. Can you tell us more about your computer, its hardware, its age, openSUSE version, Desktop used, kernel version? Anything could be of value for us to know and forgive me if you have specified any of this before.
I’m using a 2.5 yrs old HP EliteBook 8530w laptop with the following specs:
Intel Centrino 2 CPU,
Nvidia Quadro FX 770M GPU,
4 GB RAM
Samsung Syncmaster as a second screen
nvidia-settings installed (twinview enabled)
(By the way, I have always assumed this issue to be a dead end. This was also the main message of the author you quoted and in line with about everything I have ever read about this. Until I stumbled upon the tool that I linked to in the OP, that is. This basically got me hoping that there had been new developments in this field.)
So, my very first question is have you blown out the heat sinks, to remove dust, through the case vents lately? You may do this often, but if not, you need to do this right away and in particular if it has not been done in the last year of operation. My main PC is a desktop, not a laptop, but it is running openSUSE 11.4, but I have updated the kernel clear up to version 3.2.1, not that is known to help heating, in fact it may do the opposite unfortunately, though there are some work a round’s.
Actually I really think it’s just the permanent high performance mode that’s causing the high temperatures. It’s just that I’m looking for ways to get it out of high performance mode once in a while. Without the second monitor enabled the temperature is just fine, around 45C. When I’m really pushing it to the limit (i.e. so that it is in high performance mode for a reason, for a change ) it goes up to 90-100C (which is normal under those conditions, as far as I know), no difference whether the second monitor is hooked up or not.
None the less, if you have not blown out the dust and can’t tell me if you have ever done this, then you need to do so. Consider that while Linux might not be as good at heat control as Windows may be, due to better driver support, dirty heat sinks don’t help at all when used under Linux. Again, if you have not recently blown out this dust, you just must humor me and give it a try. I normally use duster spray, just cans of compressed air. I turn off the computer, unplug from the wall and remove the battery for any laptop and then blast away. Be prepared to be amazed at your dust build up. Trust me on this one.
OK. What I have been calling ‘blowing the dust out’ for years got a new meaning today. Apparently, up till now I have…let me put it this way: what I have been doing before compares to what I did today, as one brick does to a 10,000 sq ft mansion. Thanks, James, this has been a wake up call. Temperatures have dropped by almost 20 C when idle and a whopping 30 C when watching 720p video. My laptop’s life time has been extended by many, many years. Thanks!
EDIT: I even get to hear my hard disk being active now because the fans don’t need to run at maximum speed all the time!
Yea!!!, we got to the bottom of the problem. I can tell you that there are many people that just do not realize the dust build-up problem that can occur and that using some sort of compressed air is required to fix. It is further compounded in that Windows, for what ever reason, may be able to handle the situation better. Yet, dust build up will at some point take down any OS you load and cleaning it out will make every OS work better. And of course, we know if the heat gets too high, real damage can occur.
I can’t thank you enough for coming back and letting everyone know the real issue and that we must have another satisfied customer here in the openSUSE forums! lol!