Re-install Grub2 from DVD Rescue

[vta_128]

I had the same problem on my "service" computer - dual boot with WindowsXP. There was only text GRUB and a black screen. I did as caf4926 wrote and it is OK now. Thank you very much.

[miniminor]

caf4926, thank you very much, you have saved my bacon! I did a fresh install of Windows XP (don't ask) and openSUSE 12.2 on an elderly 32bit pc. Apart from some initial problems re IDE/SATA/achi all went well. openSUSE then told me I had 30+ updates (which turned out to be 100+), and I had a little "endless loop" problem here, overcome by deselecting the final item with the ! by it. An hour or so later all were downloaded, and were mostly installed when a BSOD announced a kernel panic. Rebooted, and got no further than GRUB's "ELF smaller than expected". No linux, no XP, crise cardiaque.

I had been copying onto the new installation (PATA) some files from an old SATA hard drive. Guess what? My new GRUB menu lists not only my new XP and 12.2, but also an old XP and an 11.1 on the SATA! So thank you again for some instructions which I did not understand but which have worked a miracle.

[caf4926]

Good to know it's working for you folks

[folkpuddle]

I think I have found this article just in time. After an update I have been unable to gain access to my install. All my installs have grub installed to their root partitions. I have one controlling menu.lst on a linux partition with legacy grub installed to a usb stick which works extremely well.

This my first venture into grub2 and I wasonly able to boot to my new install twice by chainloading before the update which did something I know nothing about.

It may well be that the install is damaged beyond repair but I feel like experimenting.
My root is dev/sda10

So from the dvd would I propose to mount /dev/sda10

mount /dev/sda10 /mnt

mount --bind /dev /mnt/dev

chroot /mnt

grub2-install /dev/sda10

You also mention that you did not do a grub2-mkconfig -o etc. etc. because you knew your grub.cfg was already correct

Of course I can make no such assumptions as I know nothing about whether it is right or not- I saw one posted in the forums today and it looked might complicated to me.
I will wait to hear from you in case you have another idea.
Thanks,
Hugh

[caf4926]

You can run the mkconfig once you are chroot
That will make a correct config file

Grub should be installed to sda not sda10 or whatever number
That's where sda is the boot hd, which it should typically be

[folkpuddle]

You can run the mkconfig once you are chroot
That will make a correct config file

Grub should be installed to sda not sda10 or whatever number
That's where sda is the boot hd, which it should typically be

Yes, but sda is not my boot hd. My boot drive is a usb flash drive. Legacy Grub from my first
linux installation is installed there and the menu.lst of that install contains the
entries for the other five.
The currently non-booting OS is 12.2 openSUSE which refuses to boot since the first update.

I think I'll give it a try anyway.

Running mkconfig will be my first task. Complicated business this Grub2 stuff.

Cheers,

Hugh

[caf4926]

Yes, but sda is not my boot hd. My boot drive is a usb flash drive. Legacy Grub from my first
linux installation is installed there and the menu.lst of that install contains the
entries for the other five.
The currently non-booting OS is 12.2 openSUSE which refuses to boot since the first update.

I think I'll give it a try anyway.

Running mkconfig will be my first task. Complicated business this Grub2 stuff.

Cheers,

Hugh

Then it should be written to the MBR of that as well as the partition that contains /boot
There will also be a /boot on the system target /dev/sda10, write to that as well for belt and braces

[crmrhm]

This fix worked for me (dual-boot OpenSuSE 12.2 and Windows XP). I changed labels on some partitions, which I thought was rather harmless, but on reboot, all I had was text GRUB and a black screen. This procedure set everything right again. Thanks.
Howard

[caf4926]

This fix worked for me (dual-boot OpenSuSE 12.2 and Windows XP). I changed labels on some partitions, which I thought was rather harmless, but on reboot, all I had was text GRUB and a black screen. This procedure set everything right again. Thanks.
Howard

Good to know, thanks for the feedback

[DRELKE]

Appreciate the information.

I've been running openSUSE 12.2 for about a month, and it was working fine. However, with a recent update of patches all of a sudden when booting into Linux it would simply stop at "GRUB _" (blinking cursor). Never went beyond that point for any openSUSE splash screen, etc. I do remember that one of the patches said something about GRUB, and apparently that's the culprit that has caused my recent issue. Thanks.
David

[caf4926]

Appreciate the information.

I've been running openSUSE 12.2 for about a month, and it was working fine. However, with a recent update of patches all of a sudden when booting into Linux it would simply stop at "GRUB _" (blinking cursor). Never went beyond that point for any openSUSE splash screen, etc. I do remember that one of the patches said something about GRUB, and apparently that's the culprit that has caused my recent issue. Thanks.
David

Hope that fixed it for you David

[folkpuddle]

Hello again,

Sorry I was ill since I last posted - but I do have an update.

I also had the upper case words GRUB when I first reported the incident.
From a grub2 troubleshooting article:

GRUB - a single word at the top left of the screen, with no prompt and no cursor.
GRUB has failed to find even the most basic information, usually contained in the MBR or boot sector.

After running the grub rescue re-install from DVD I ended up with a grub prompt.
This in itself is an improvement but I was still unable to effect a successful boot.

I have a long week in bed to think about this and I feel that it is not worth proceeding.
I already have another successful openSUSE 12.2 install with legacy grub in the root partition and the
relevant paragraph cut and pasted to the menu.lst of the multiboot controlling linux install which has its legacy grub installed
to the mbr of a usb stick.

Hi best wishes to all those who wrote in with success stories.
Well done,

Hugh

[caf4926]

Hugh,

You need to tell us more about the system setup. Partitions / HD's etc

[folkpuddle]

Hugh,

You need to tell us more about the system setup. Partitions / HD's etc

Helo again,

I persevered after all.

Here is what I did. My last report said I had a grub prompt which was an improvement.
The grub prompt turned out to be legacy grub. With my knowledge of Legacy Grub I was able to
check out the geometry of the hard drives ( I have two installed) to make sure grub knew where it was installed.
Aha. Grub thought it was installed on (hd1,9) and not on (hd0,9) or sdb10 instead of sda10.

Armed with this insight I was able to issue the following commands at the legacy grub prompt:

grub>root (hd1,9)
grub>kernel /boot/vmlinuzn(umbersofkernelhere).desktop root=/dev/sdb10 ro
grub>initrd /boot/initrd(numbersofimagehere)
grub>boot

And it did. It booted into the lost openSUSE.

Next step was to reinstall Grub2.
For that I opened a terminal as root and issued the following command

grub2-install --force /dev/sda10

still at the root prompt I issued the grub2-mkconfig -o /boot/grub2/grub.cfg string as shown in your article.

Al is well now. I was able to continue to boot to the 'lost' install and last night I finished off by
installing nvidia the hard way with jcdaniel's excellent script.

Best wishes,

Hugh

[Relative]

Appreciate the information.

I've been running openSUSE 12.2 for about a month, and it was working fine. However, with a recent update of patches all of a sudden when booting into Linux it would simply stop at "GRUB _" (blinking cursor). Never went beyond that point for any openSUSE splash screen, etc. I do remember that one of the patches said something about GRUB, and apparently that's the culprit that has caused my recent issue. Thanks.
David

I also was running fine, but just for the day I installed from scratch. It was after the patches (GRUB was in there somewhere) that I wound up at the same point. Just a stop at "GRUB _" (blinking cursor). This procedure fixed me right up - so far.

Many thanks from me too.

Mike Cebula

[caf4926]

I also was running fine, but just for the day I installed from scratch. It was after the patches (GRUB was in there somewhere) that I wound up at the same point. Just a stop at "GRUB _" (blinking cursor). This procedure fixed me right up - so far.

Many thanks from me too.

Mike Cebula

I'm just pleased folks can actually understand the things I put together.

[mrmazda]

Grub should be installed to sda not sda10 or whatever number
That's where sda is the boot hd, which it should typically be

To minimize likelihood to need repairing multiboot with Windows, the MBR is where Grub/Grub2 should not be, regardless where the Grub2 devs insist it belongs. see: Bugs/grub - openSUSE

[londy]

Thanks for posting this. I was messing around with the boot partition and ended up with an unbootable system. Your instructions saved me.

I want to add a tip for people using encrypted lvm. Instead of starting the rescue system, just start the installation. On the second step, it'll ask for your passphrase and setup your lvm. After that hit alt+ctrl+f2 and do the rest of the rescue from there.

[MirceaKitsune]

Thank you for this very useful article! I've never had issues with grub/grub2 on my main machine (thank goodness) but I did some experiments on an openSUSE VM and broke grub2. The machine was dispensable, but I wanted to learn how to repair it in case grub ever breaks on my primary machine. I followed those steps and grub was indeed re-installed properly and would work again (openSUSE 12.2).

[HRGargi]

Same for me! I just tried it on a VM in case of a real breakdown of my bootloader. These steps are working without any problems. Thanks for that article!